Skip to content
SearchSee plans and prices

Soft 404 on WordPress: the page says it is missing, and answers 200

A soft 404 is a page Google reads as a "not found" message without a 404 status. The help page says to send 404 for pages that are really gone, and to put more on the page when it is a real page. WordPress's own missing-page template answers 404.

By
WP Ministry
Published

In short

  • Google's help calls it a friendly "not found" message that was not sent with a 404 status.
  • Its crawler documentation says a 2xx page whose content looks like an error, an empty page or an error message is reported as a soft 404.
  • For a page that is really gone, send 404. For a page that should be indexed, add more than the error sentence.
  • WordPress's own "Page not found" template is sent with a 404. A theme that shows that message with a 200 is the fault.
  • The URL Inspection live test can show a screenshot of the rendered page. That is how Google says to see what it saw.
  • Whether the row clears is Google's reading of a later crawl.

A soft 404 is Google's name for a page that reads as "not found" and was not sent with a 404 status. The Page indexing report says it in those words: the request returns what Google thinks is a soft 404, meaning a user-friendly "not found" message without a 404 HTTP response code. The help page recommends a 404 for pages that are truly not found, and more information on the page when you want Google to see that it is not a soft 404.

Google's documentation of HTTP status codes says the same thing from the crawler's side. A 2xx response is eligible to be processed. If the content suggests an error, an empty page or an error message, Search Console shows a soft 404. A real 404 is not indexed, and an address that used to be indexed is dropped. A 410 is treated the same way.

"Not found (404)" in Search Console is the other row. There the server did send 404. That page also says not to answer 200 with a not-found message, which is this status.

See the status code

The help page says to run a live URL inspection and open "View tested page" for a screenshot of what Google rendered.

From a terminal, this prints the status line. Put an address from the report in place of the example.

bash
curl -s -o /dev/null -D - "https://example.com/old-page/" | head -n 1

HTTP/1.1 200 together with a not-found message is the soft 404. HTTP/1.1 404 is a normal not-found, which WordPress sends for a missing post when the theme has not replaced that behavior. Fix 404 Not Found on posts and pages that exist is the case where the page should load and does not.

What causes it

  • A missing address answers 200 and says it is missing

    Common

    Google's help says a soft 404 returns a user-friendly not-found message without a 404 code. Its HTTP documentation says a 2xx response whose content suggests an error, an empty page or an error message is shown as a soft 404 in Search Console.

    Fix: Send 404 for an address that is gone

  • Missing addresses are sent to the home page or to a search page

    Sometimes

    A redirect of many old addresses to one page is a pattern other pages on this site already flag beside this status. Google's help for a real 404 says to use a 301 when a page has moved, and to leave a 404 when it was removed with nothing to replace it.

    Fix: Stop sending missing addresses to one page

  • The address is a real URL with almost nothing on it

    Sometimes

    The help page's other recommendation is to add more information on the page so Google can tell it is not a soft 404. An empty category or a filter that matches nothing can read as "no results" on a 200.

    Fix: Add a real page, or stop publishing the empty one

How to fix it

Send 404 for an address that is gone

  • Takes care
  • Low risk
  • About 20 minutes
  1. Step 1: Confirm the 200

    Run the command above on two or three examples. If they are 404 already, this is not the cause. Look at the rendered page in the live test instead.

  2. Step 2: Find what replaced WordPress's 404

    WordPress's own missing-page template is sent with a 404, which the Search Console 404 page records. A theme or a plugin that shows "nothing found" inside the normal page template leaves the status at 200. The template to look for is the one those examples use. A custom design is fine. The status has to stay 404 for an address that does not exist.

  3. Step 3: Fetch the address again

    The first line should be a 404. Leave the row in the report until Google crawls it. A 404 is not a soft 404.

Do not redirect the missing address to the home page to get it out of the report. That is the next cause.

Stop sending missing addresses to one page

  • Takes care
  • Low risk
  • About 30 minutes

Google's help for a genuine 404 says to use a 301 when the page has moved, and that a 404 is appropriate when the page was removed and has no replacement.

  1. Step 1: See where the example lands

    The redirect checker shows a hop to the home page or to a search URL. "Page with redirect" explains a redirect that is doing its job. A rule that sends every unknown address to the home page is not one of those.

  2. Step 2: Point a moved page at its new address

    One old address, one 301, one new page. How to set up redirects is the method. A redesign's list belongs in the redesign checklist.

  3. Step 3: Let the rest 404

    An address with no successor should 404, not load the home page. The home page's status will be 200, and the body will not be a not-found message, but Google fetched the home page under the old address. That is the shape this status describes.

Add a real page, or stop publishing the empty one

  • Easy
  • No risk
  • About 20 minutes

The help page's second recommendation is to add more information so the page is not only an error message.

  1. Step 1: Open the example

    A category with no posts, a filter that matches nothing, or a published page whose only text is "not found" fits the description. The live test's screenshot is what Google rendered.

  2. Step 2: Choose one

    Write the page so it is the thing a visitor came for, or remove it and let the address 404. An empty category that you want as a landing page needs the description and the posts. One you do not want should not be a public address. Out-of-stock products is the store's version of a page that still has a URL and little to show.

A WordPress SEO audit is the right size when the list is a redesign's old addresses and the redirects were sent to the home page in bulk.

Common questions

Is a soft 404 a broken page?

It is a page Google does not trust as a real result. Visitors may see a polite message. The server told Google the request succeeded. Google's help asks for a 404 when the page is gone, so the address can leave the index the way a real 404 does.

WordPress already has a 404 template. Why am I here?

Because something is not using it. A plugin, a theme, or a redirect to the home page answers 200 for an address WordPress would have 404'd. The status line from the command on this page says which.

Should empty search results be a 404?

WordPress answers a search with 200 and noindex, which the no-plugin guide records. A noindex is reported under its own reason, not as a soft 404, once Google has read the tag. This status is the 200 whose body looks like an error and does not say noindex.

Will Google index the page after I add more text?

Not by promise. The help page says the extra information is how you show the page is not a soft 404. Indexing after that is still Google's decision. A 2xx status does not guarantee indexing, which is Google's own wording on HTTP status codes.

When to get help

When a theme or a plugin sends 200 for missing addresses and you cannot find the template, or when a redesign redirected hundreds of old URLs to the home page. The status code is one request. The map of old addresses is the longer job.

More on this subject

Would you rather we fixed it?

SEO audit is $249. A written audit, each finding with its source, and up to 2 hours of fixes done and tested again.

More about this work: WordPress SEO audit

May we measure how this site is used?

A yes notes the pages of this visit and loads Google Analytics. A no keeps and loads nothing. See the cookies page.

If you say yes, we note the pages you look at during this visit and load Google Analytics. If you say no, nothing is kept and nothing is loaded. The site works the same either way. The cookies page has the details.